StoreRouter vs. Shopify Catalog
Product discovery beyond a commerce platform.
Your agent's product selection shouldn't depend on which ecommerce platform a store uses—or whether its merchant has joined another catalog network. StoreRouter indexes covered storefronts across ecommerce platforms and adds a shared semantic layer so agents can search, filter, and compare products even when merchant labels are inconsistent.
- /v1/products/search
- /v1/products/parse
- JSON · Markdown
Evidence recorded October 20, 2026 · StoreRouter, formerly Octogen
| Capability | StoreRouter | Shopify Catalog |
|---|---|---|
| Catalog foundation | Independent index of covered storefronts | Products available through Shopify's catalog network |
| Merchant participation | Supported public storefronts; no merchant-submitted feed required | Native Shopify data, plus imports and ongoing sync for participating non-Shopify merchants |
| Product understanding | Shared taxonomy, normalized fields, and semantic enrichment on indexed products | Structured product data with normalized options and AI-inferred fields |
| Search filters | Category, price, and taxonomy attributes such as pattern, fabric and fit | Category, price, and three attributes: color, size and target gender |
| Custom storefront content | Store-specific extraction can incorporate available storefront sources | Configurable field mappings for custom Shopify data |
| Developer workflow | Search covered catalogs; parse a product URL into a shared schema | Search and retrieve products through Shopify's catalog interfaces |
Fit
Which fits your agent?
Choose StoreRouter when
you need discovery across covered Shopify and non-Shopify storefronts, with a shared product schema and semantic enrichment that doesn't depend on merchants maintaining a Shopify integration.
Choose Shopify Catalog when
its participating catalog fits your needs and you want product discovery within its broader agentic commerce workflow, including cart and checkout integrations. Shopify's agent tools.
Product understanding
Understand the product beyond the merchant's labels
A shopper asks for a linen summer dress. The merchant may call it “The Sunday,” tag it “New Season,” and put its fabric composition in a separate details panel. Useful product search needs to connect those facts to what the shopper means.
StoreRouter's enrichment layer interprets product information into a shared taxonomy and attributes such as material, fit, style, pattern, and occasion. That gives agents a consistent vocabulary across stores, without requiring each merchant to label products the same way. It can also help recover useful meaning from incomplete or incorrect merchant categorization when the available product evidence supports it.
The linen dress is an illustrative example. The recorded run below measures search results on real shopping queries. Derived attributes can be incomplete or wrong; enrichment is not a guarantee that every label is corrected.
The storefront can contain more than the core product record
A storefront can combine commerce data with a content management system (CMS), a product information management system (PIM), or a review service. Depending on the integration, those details may be synced into the commerce platform or appear only in the customer-facing experience.
StoreRouter's store-specific extraction can use available storefront sources to assemble the product record before normalization and enrichment. The aim is to capture the information needed to understand the product, including details outside the store's default product fields. Actual fields depend on the source and extractor.
Shopify supports custom mappings from product attributes, metafields, and metaobjects. It also documents inferred descriptions and attributes including material, style, and occasion. Both systems interpret product data; a claim that one captures more detail requires a comparison of actual product records. Catalog Mapping · Inferred fields.
Recorded run · 2026-10-20
Same shopping queries, judged blind
We ran seven attribute-heavy fashion searches on both engines and took the top 10 results from each. StoreRouter received each search with its filters. Shopify received the closest search it supports: the same words, with category, gender and color mapped to its own filters. A judge saw each query's 20 results shuffled together and judged every one without knowing which engine returned it or at what rank.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Paisley silk neckties | ||
| Glossy women's shoes with buckles | ||
| Women's casual white poplin dresses | ||
| Women's flared dark-wash jeans, loose fit | ||
| Men's canvas chore jackets | ||
| Sports league graphic t-shirts | ||
| Gold-frame, pink-tint sunglasses | ||
| Matches in the top 10, all queries | 60/70 | 40/70 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attributes | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Ones Shopify can filter on: category, gender, color | ||
| Ones Shopify can't filter on: pattern, fabric, fit, finish, closure, lens, frame |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
- Where Shopify can filter, the engines tie. Results matched the requested category, gender and color 99% of the time on both.
- The gap is in the attributes Shopify can't filter on. Its catalog search filters on category, price, and three attributes: color, size and target gender. Pattern, fabric, finish, closure and lens tint reach it only as words in the query. For glossy shoes with buckles, 1 of Shopify's top 10 matched; most were matte knit Mary Janes. For gold-frame, pink-tint sunglasses, 2 matched; most had pink plastic frames.
- Shopify won one query. For men's canvas chore jackets it returned 9 matches to StoreRouter's 5. StoreRouter's chore and barn jacket category included zip-front work jackets, which the judge marked as partial matches. We're fixing that category.
Seven queries from our own curated searches, run once, with one AI judge per query. The run shows where the engines differ on attribute-heavy searches; it does not measure overall relevance. Unknowns are excluded from the attribute rates. See Methodology.
Attribute detail by query
Each attribute Shopify can't filter on, per query: the share of each engine's 10 results judged to have it.
| Query: attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Neckties: paisley pattern | ||
| Neckties: silk | ||
| Buckle shoes: buckle closure | ||
| Buckle shoes: glossy finish | ||
| Poplin dresses: cotton or poplin | ||
| Poplin dresses: solid color | ||
| Jeans: dark wash | ||
| Jeans: wide-leg, flare or jogger shape | ||
| Jeans: loose or wide-leg fit | ||
| Chore jackets: canvas | ||
| T-shirts: logo, photo or slogan graphic | ||
| Sunglasses: gold temples | ||
| Sunglasses: pink lenses | ||
| Sunglasses: metal frame |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
Where Shopify kept up, it was on attributes its sellers put in product titles, such as paisley, poplin and canvas. Its widest gaps were finish, frame material and fit, which are usually visible in a photo but rarely written in a title.
Recorded run · 2026-10-20
Every result the judges saw
Open a query to see both engines' top 10 as the judges rated them: each result's verdict, the requested attributes it lacked, and the judge's note. Titles link to the merchant's product page.
Titles, sellers and prices are as each engine returned them on October 20, 2026, and may have changed since. Judges saw the results shuffled together, without the engine or the rank.
Paisley silk neckties: StoreRouter 10/10 · Shopify 9/10
The shopper searched for paisley silk neckties. Shopify filtered on category and gender. It cannot filter on paisley pattern and silk, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: neckties | ||
| Paisley pattern | ||
| Silk | ||
| Gender: men |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1matchBarry. Wang Golden Paisley Necktie for Men Silk Wedding Tie Hanky Cufflinks SetBarry. Wang · $14.99
- 2
- 3
- 4partialHi-Tie Paisley Silk Necktie & Pocket Square – Dark Green Blackimage shows a check pattern, not paisleyQme · $22.02 · not paisley pattern
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Glossy women's shoes with buckles: StoreRouter 10/10 · Shopify 1/10
The shopper searched for glossy women's shoes with buckles. Shopify filtered on category and gender. It cannot filter on buckle closure and glossy finish, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: flats & loafers | ||
| Buckle closure | ||
| Glossy finish | ||
| Gender: women |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10matchbuckle-fastening patent-leather pumpstitled pumps but shown as a flat Mary JaneMoschino · $594.00
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1partialThe Double Buckle Mary Jane - Chocolate Meshmesh, not glossyRothy's · $165.00 · not glossy finish
- 2
- 3partialThe Square Mary Jane - Lollipop Redred knit, not glossy; buckle not visibleRothy's · $100.00 · not glossy finish
- 4missCelina - Blackmatte leather, hook-and-loop strapOrthofeet® · $99.99 · not buckle closure, glossy finish
- 5
- 6partialThe Espadrille Mary Jane - Blue Breezeblue knit espadrille, not glossyRothy's · $150.00 · not glossy finish
- 7matchMary Jane Shoes For Women | Platform Chunky Buckle Strapchunky platform Mary JaneGrace Colley · $104.95
- 8missThe Knot Point II - Blackknit knot flat; no buckle, not glossyRothy's · $99.00 · not buckle closure, glossy finish
- 9
- 10missThe Point II - Deep Navyplain knit flat; no buckle, not glossyRothy's · $109.00 · not buckle closure, glossy finish
Women's casual white poplin dresses: StoreRouter 10/10 · Shopify 9/10
The shopper searched for casual white poplin dress. Shopify filtered on category, gender and color. It cannot filter on cotton or poplin and solid color, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: dresses | ||
| Cotton or poplin | ||
| Solid color | ||
| Gender: women | ||
| Color: white |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6partialFaherty Women’s Coastal Poplin Emmy Dressshown in blue, not white; title gives no colorThe Spot Boutique · $228.00 · not color: white
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Women's flared dark-wash jeans, loose fit: StoreRouter 8/10 · Shopify 6/10
The shopper searched for dark wash flared jeans. Shopify filtered on category and gender. It cannot filter on dark wash, wide-leg, flare or jogger shape and loose or wide-leg fit, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: jeans | ||
| Gender: women | ||
| Dark wash | ||
| Wide-leg, flare or jogger shape | ||
| Loose or wide-leg fit |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6matchJen Wide Leg Flare Denim Jeans - Dark BlueClose call: titled dark blue, photo reads mid-darkMeshki · $99.00
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10matchFlirty Expectations Low Rise Denim JeansTitle omits flare, but the photo shows a dark flarecurrent mood · $55.20
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1matchRestock! Judy Blue The Amelia Dark Wash Tummy Control Flare Jeans with Booty Lifting PocketsClose call: shaping flare, fitted through hip and thighFreckled Poppy · $84.90
- 2
- 3partialZariyah Tinted Dark Wash Stacked Flare JeanSkin-tight stacked flare; photo shows heavily faded, distressed tint, not a clean dark washRockstar Original · $29.99 · not loose or wide-leg fit
- 4
- 5matchJudy Blue "The Sadie" Multi Inseam High Rise Dark Wash Trouser Flare JeansFreckled Poppy · $79.90
- 6
- 7
- 8partialFiona High Waisted Bell Bottom Flare Jeans - Medium Wash DenimMedium wash, not darkWillow Boutique · $57.32 · not dark wash
- 9partialRestock! Judy Blue The Alex High Rise Dark Wash Kick Flare JeansCropped slim kick flare; photo looks medium wash despite the titleFreckled Poppy · $74.90 · not loose or wide-leg fit
- 10partialTurn Back Time Flare Jeans - Dark WashSkin-tight bodycon flare, not looseFashion Nova · $39.99 · not loose or wide-leg fit
Men's canvas chore jackets: StoreRouter 5/10 · Shopify 9/10
The shopper searched for men's canvas chore jacket. Shopify filtered on category and gender. It cannot filter on canvas, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: chore & barn jackets | ||
| Gender: men | ||
| Canvas |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5partialMen's Cotton Canvas Zip-Front Depot Jacketzip Detroit-style work jacket, not a chore coatLevi's · $150.00
- 6partialx Carhartt cotton canvas jacketblazer-style lapels; designer hybrid, not a classic chore cutMytheresa · $640.00
- 7missMen's Shapers Canvas Jackethooded zip jacket, not a chore or barn jacketHurley · $109.95 · not category: chore & barn jackets
- 8
- 9
- 10matchCarhartt Chore Jacketlooks like duck canvas but fabric and gender not statedJustinreed · $20.00
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3matchKnowlton Canvas Chore Jacketzip front with stand collar; looks closer to a field jacketKanuk · $530.00
- 4matchLucky Brand Workwear Men's Canvas Chore Quilted Lined Jacketzip front, but titled chore jacketWork World · $139.99
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10matchMen's Regular Fit Heavyweight Jacket in Cotton Canvas - 470 GSM | Canvas Chore Jacket 5524Organic Blank US · $64.52
Sports league graphic t-shirts: StoreRouter 8/10 · Shopify 4/10
The shopper searched for sports league graphic t-shirt. Shopify filtered on category. It cannot filter on logo, photo or slogan graphic, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: t-shirts | ||
| Logo, photo or slogan graphic |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9partialSP5DER CHAMPIONS LEAGUE TEE BLACKSp5der brand graphic, not a sports leagueSolesystemshop · $160.00
- 10
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1
- 2partialLebron James Bubble Gum Graphic T-ShirtLeBron face art, no team or league brandingIcy · $35.00
- 3
- 4match'G.O.A.T' GRAPHIC TEEKobe vs Jordan art with Lakers/Bulls names; athlete art, close callHYPEDEPT · $34.99
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Gold-frame, pink-tint sunglasses: StoreRouter 9/10 · Shopify 2/10
The shopper searched for gold frame pink tint sunglasses. Shopify filtered on category. It cannot filter on gold temples, pink lenses and metal frame, so those reached it only as words in the query; they are the bold rows below.
| Query | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 |
- Match
- Partial
- Miss
- No result
- One cell per rank, best first.
| Requested attribute | StoreRouter | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Category: sunglasses | ||
| Gold temples | ||
| Pink lenses | ||
| Metal frame |
- Yes
- No
- Unknown
- Rate is yes / (yes + no); unknowns are not counted.
StoreRouter · 10 returned
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
Shopify · 10 returned
- 1partialAllure - Pink Tortoise Polarizedpink tortoise acetate frame, not gold metalShady Rays® | Polarized Sunglasses · $58.00 · not gold temples, metal frame
- 2
- 3missSANDRA - LIGHT PINK CRYSTAL + DUSK GRADIENT SUNGLASSESpink acetate frame, brown gradient lensDIFF Eyewear · $59.00 · not gold temples, pink lenses, metal frame
- 4partialButtery Brospink patterned plastic frame, not gold metalBlenders Eyewear · $69.00 · not gold temples, metal frame
- 5
- 6partialButtery Brospink plastic shield, rainbow-pink mirror lensBlenders Eyewear · $69.00 · not gold temples, metal frame
- 7partialBOMBSHELL | GOLD PINK CRUSHpink plastic temples on rimless shieldEyewear Index · AUD 69.00 · not gold temples
- 8missEpoch Eyewear Vibe Rose Polarized Sunglasses – Pink Frame Rose Gold Mirror Lenspink plastic frame; rose gold mirror lens reads copperSunglassPatrol.com · $25.00 · not gold temples, metal frame
- 9matchGold Frame Pink Lens Square Sunglassesclose call: gradient lens reads brownish-pinkBella Lusy · $88.00
- 10missBELLA - LIGHT PINK CRYSTAL + WINE GRADIENT SUNGLASSESpink acetate frame, wine-brown gradient lensDIFF Eyewear · $124.00 · not gold temples, pink lenses, metal frame
Platform independence
Reach stores without requiring them to join Shopify
Platform independence matters when the stores your shoppers want use different commerce systems. StoreRouter's coverage is built by indexing storefronts. A supported store does not need to migrate to Shopify or maintain a Shopify catalog for StoreRouter to include its products. Developers query one schema across the catalogs we cover.
Shopify's Agentic plan lets non-Shopify merchants participate while keeping their existing stores. They must import products and keep them current in Shopify; documented options include CSV, API synchronization, and PIM connectors. Agentic plan setup.
For an agent developer, the distinction is concrete: StoreRouter can add coverage through storefront integration without waiting for the merchant to set up that Shopify connection.
Platform independence does not mean universal coverage. Check the coverage directory for the stores your application needs.
Before you build
Integration notes
- Does Shopify enrich product data too?
Yes. Shopify documents AI-inferred descriptions and product attributes as well as normalized options. Shopify's inferred fields.
The difference in our recorded run was what search can filter on. StoreRouter filters on enriched attributes such as pattern, fabric and fit. Shopify's catalog search filters on category, price, color, size and target gender, so other attributes depend on the query text.
- Is every StoreRouter Parse response enriched?
No. Semantic enrichment is available on indexed products. On-demand Parse does not run enrichment, so those responses can be sparser.
- Can I use both?
Yes. Evaluate StoreRouter for independent product discovery and Shopify's commerce tools where the merchant and workflow support them. StoreRouter focuses on discovery and product data; it does not provide checkout.
- Does an agent developer have to upload merchant feeds?
Using Shopify Catalog does not require the agent developer to upload every participating merchant's feed. The import and synchronization work described here is for non-Shopify merchants joining through the Agentic plan. Merchant setup guide.
Start with the stores your shoppers care about
Check coverage, try a real shopping query, and inspect the attributes your agent needs to make a recommendation.
Documentation reviewed · 2026-10-09
Sources and scope
This page compares documented approaches and one recorded search run on seven queries. It does not establish relevance beyond those queries, more accurate enrichment, broader total coverage, or fresher prices.
- Shopify catalog interfaces: catalog scope and product discovery tools.
- Global Catalog inferred fields: generated and enriched product information.
- Catalog Mapping: custom data sources and product grouping.
- Agentic plan setup: product imports and ongoing synchronization for non-Shopify merchants.
Shopify's developer overview describes Global Catalog in terms of Shopify merchants, while its Agentic plan help docs explain non-Shopify participation. We do not assume every Agentic plan import is exposed identically through every developer interface or AI channel.
Methodology
How the search run was recorded
- Queries. The seven product searches in our Cosimo shopping app's curated set, unchanged, run once on October 20, 2026. Their filters use StoreRouter's taxonomy; they were not written for this comparison.
- StoreRouter.
POST /v1/products/searchwith the query text and its filters. - Shopify. The
search_catalogtool on Shopify's catalog MCP server, anonymous, with buyer country US: the request Shopify'sshopCLI sends. Category became Shopify taxonomy categories, gender becameTarget genderand color becameColor. Other filters reached Shopify only as words in the query. Shopify returns purchasable items by default. - Judging. Each query's 20 results were pooled, shuffled and renamed. One AI judge per query saw only what both engines return: title, seller, price, colors offered and the first image. Neither engine's derived attributes were shown. Each result was judged a match, partial or miss, and each requested attribute yes, no or unknown.
- Scoring. Matches in the top 10 count results judged a match. Attribute rates are yes / (yes + no). StoreRouter results had 18 unknowns and Shopify results had 24; neither is counted.
- Not tested. Queries with no filters on either side, signed-in Shopify search with saved preferences, price and stock accuracy, and coverage.